Skip to main content

ICW Test Design: E7:S06:T10-T16 – Workflow Windsurf Impact Reviews

ICW Instance: ICW-E7S06-T10-T16 Host Tasks: E7:S06:T10 through E7:S06:T16 Phase: Test Design Created: 2026-03-18 Specification Reference: ICW-E7S06-T10-T16 Specification Status: Complete

Executive Summary​

Test design validates the review deliverable (document), not code. All checks are checklist-style or document-structure validation. Each review document produced by T10-T16 must pass the applicable REV-N checks before the task is considered complete.

Test Strategy​

Objectives​

  • Verify review documents contain all required sections
  • Verify skill mappings are complete and correct
  • Verify migration plans are actionable and reference T01
  • Verify anti-pattern vigilance findings are documented

Scope​

In scope:

  • Document structure (sections present)
  • Completeness of skill mappings
  • Migration plan feasibility and traceability
  • Anti-pattern section coverage

Out of scope:

  • Automated test execution (manual checklist)
  • Cross-document consistency across T10-T16

Completeness Checks​

REV-001: Windsurf Impact Section​

Test IDDescriptionPreconditionsStepsExpected Result
REV-001Review doc contains "Windsurf Impact" sectionReview document existsSearch for section headerSection present with content

REV-002: Skill Mappings Section​

Test IDDescriptionPreconditionsStepsExpected Result
REV-002Review doc contains "Skill Mappings" sectionReview document existsSearch for section; verify at least one mapping or "no relevant skills"Section present; either lists mappings or states no relevant skills

Note: For T13, T14, T16, "no relevant skills" is acceptable.

REV-003: Migration Plan Section​

Test IDDescriptionPreconditionsStepsExpected Result
REV-003Review doc contains "Migration Plan" section with actionable stepsReview document existsSearch for section; verify steps reference T01Section present with ordered steps for T01

REV-004: Anti-Pattern Findings Section​

Test IDDescriptionPreconditionsStepsExpected Result
REV-004Review doc contains "Anti-Pattern Findings" sectionReview document existsSearch for sectionSection present; contains findings or "none observed"

REV-005: Inputs Consulted​

Test IDDescriptionPreconditionsStepsExpected Result
REV-005All inputs from task doc were consultedTask doc availableVerify review references .cursorrules, .windsurf, workflow YAMLEvidence that all inputs were analyzed

REV-006: Migration Plan References​

Test IDDescriptionPreconditionsStepsExpected Result
REV-006Migration plan references T01 and .cursor/skills/ or .cursorrulesMigration plan section existsSearch for T01, .cursor/skills/, .cursorrulesAll referenced

REV-007: Anti-Pattern Addresses Deterministic vs Agentic​

Test IDDescriptionPreconditionsStepsExpected Result
REV-007Anti-pattern section addresses deterministic vs agentic concernAnti-pattern section existsVerify content discusses scripts vs agentic reasoningConcern explicitly addressed

Correctness Checks​

REV-008: Skill Mappings Match .windsurf Contents​

Test IDDescriptionPreconditionsStepsExpected Result
REV-008Skill mappings list matches .windsurf/skills/ contents for that workflowMapping table from spec; .windsurf/skills/ existsCompare review's skill list to spec table and actual .windsurf/skills/No omissions; no false positives

Note: N/A for T13, T14, T16 if "no relevant skills."

REV-009: Migration Plan Feasibility​

Test IDDescriptionPreconditionsStepsExpected Result
REV-009Migration plan is feasibleMigration plan existsVerify target paths exist; no circular dependenciesPaths valid; steps executable

REV-010: Findings Traceable​

Test IDDescriptionPreconditionsStepsExpected Result
REV-010Findings are traceableReview has findingsVerify "skill X does Y" has file reference or clear provenanceEach finding has traceability

Pass Criteria​

  • All applicable REV-N checks pass per task
  • Tasks with no .windsurf skills (T13, T14, T16): REV-002 accepts "no relevant skills"; REV-008 is N/A
  • One failure = review not complete; fix and re-check